Ping iSI Vs Modern Irons: Which One Should You Choose?

Golf enthusiasts are always looking for the perfect set of clubs to improve their game. With so many options available in the market, it can be difficult to choose the right one. Two popular options are Ping iSi irons and modern irons. 

The main differences between Ping ISI and modern irons are design and technology advancements. Ping ISI irons, released in the 1990s, have a classic cavity-back design with perimeter weighting. Modern irons incorporate newer technologies such as thinner faces, multi-material construction, and improved weight distribution for enhanced forgiveness, distance, and playability.

In this blog post, we’ll take a closer look at the Ping iSI irons and compare them to modern irons to help you make an informed decision on which set of irons is right for you.

Overview of Ping iSI irons

The Ping iSi irons are a series of golf clubs produced by Ping, a leading golf equipment manufacturer. These irons are designed for golfers of all skill levels and offer a balance of forgiveness and control. 

The iSi model features perimeter weighting and a progressive offset design, which helps to increase accuracy and stability. 

The clubs have a traditional look and feel and are made from high-quality materials to ensure durability and performance. 

Ping also offers custom fittings to help golfers choose the best iSi irons for their individual swing characteristics.

Overview of Ping modern irons

The Ping Modern Irons are a series of golf clubs produced by Ping, a leading golf equipment manufacturer. 

These irons are designed for golfers who are looking for a modern, high-performance club that delivers a blend of distance, control, and versatility. 

They feature a compact shape, clean lines, and advanced materials and technologies to improve performance. 

The clubs are available in multiple configurations to suit golfers with different swing types and preferences and can be custom fit to ensure optimal performance on the course.

Ping iSi Vs Modern Irons: Quick Comparison Table

To help you compare and decide which is right, we have created a table highlighting the key differences between these two types of irons. 

FeaturePing iSi IronsModern Irons
DesignClassic, simple, blade-style headModern, intricate, various shapes
WeightingConventional, smaller sweet spotAdvanced weighting systems, larger sweet spot
MaterialMild carbon steelCutting-edge materials (titanium, high-strength steel, carbon fiber)
TechnologyNoneLaunch monitors, adjustable weights, custom fitting options
PerformanceTraditional look, feel, lower launch, and spinForgiving, higher ball speed, longer distance, better control
Shaft optionsSteelGraphite and other lightweight materials
FeelFirmer, crisp feedbackSofter
PriceMore affordableVaries depending on technology and materials
CustomizationLimited optionsOptions for customizing look and feel
Launch conditionsLower launch, less spinHigher launch, more spin
ForgivenessLess forgivingMore forgiving
VersatilityLimitedSuitable for a wide range of skill levels and playing preferences

What are the differences between ping iSi and modern irons?


So far, we have covered the basics with brief differences between ping isi and modern irons. Now let’s have a detailed look at their differences and how they can affect your game-


The Ping iSi irons have a classic and simple design, with a straight top line, minimal offset, and a blade-style head shape. 

Modern irons have more intricate designs, with larger head sizes, thicker top lines, and more offset, as well as innovative shapes such as cavity backs and hollow bodies.


Ping iSi irons have a conventional weight distribution in the center of the club head, which can result in a smaller sweet spot and reduced forgiveness on off-center hits. 

Modern irons employ advanced weighing systems such as perimeter weighting, distributing weight around the edges of the club head for improved stability and an enlarged sweet spot.


Modern irons often incorporate cutting-edge materials such as titanium, high-strength steel, and carbon fiber, which are lighter and stronger than the materials used in traditional irons. 

This enables the creation of thinner club faces and deeper cavities for enhanced performance and feel. The Ping iSi irons, on the other hand, are made of mild carbon steel and do not have the same level of advanced materials as modern irons.


Modern irons are equipped with advanced technology, such as launch monitors, adjustable weights, and custom fitting options. 

Launch monitors provide golfers with the optimal launch conditions for their shots, while adjustable weights allow players to fine-tune the weight of their irons to match their swing.

Custom fitting options offer golfers the ability to have irons tailored to their unique swing and physical characteristics. The Ping iSi irons do not have these technological features.


Modern irons are designed to be more forgiving, generate higher ball speeds, provide long distances, and offer better control compared to classic irons like the Ping iSi. 

The advanced materials, shapes, and weighting systems in modern irons make them easier to hit, more stable on off-center shots, and more consistent in performance. 

However, some golfers may prefer the traditional look, feel, and performance of classic irons like the Ping iSi, particularly if they have a lower handicap or prefer the traditional style.

Shaft options

Ping iSi irons typically come with steel shafts, while modern irons often offer a wider range of shaft options, including graphite and other lightweight materials. This allows golfers to choose a shaft that suits their swing speed and feel preference.


Modern irons are often designed to provide a softer feel, thanks to the use of advanced materials and construction techniques. Ping iSi irons, on the other hand, have a more traditional feel that some golfers prefer for their firmer, crisp feedback.


Ping iSi irons are typically more affordable than modern ones due to their simpler design and construction. 

However, the cost of modern irons can vary greatly depending on the technology and materials used in their construction.


Modern irons often come with options for customizing the look and feel, including different finishes, shaft lengths, and grip sizes. 

Ping iSi irons do not have as many customization options, as they are designed to have a classic look that appeals to a wider range of golfers.

Launch conditions

Modern irons are designed to launch the ball higher and with more spin, which can help golfers achieve optimal launch conditions for their shots. 

Ping iSi irons tend to launch the ball lower and with less spin, which can be preferable for golfers with a lower handicap who are looking for more control and workability.


Modern irons often have larger head sizes, deeper cavities, and more advanced weighting systems, making them more forgiving on off-center shots. 

Ping iSi irons have a smaller sweet spot and less forgiveness, which can make them more challenging for golfers who struggle with accuracy.


Modern irons are often designed to be more versatile, with different models that can suit golfers with a wide range of skill levels and playing preferences. 

Ping iSi irons are typically designed for golfers who prefer a more traditional look and feel and may not have as much versatility as modern irons.

Ping iSi Or Modern Irons: Which One Should You Choose?

The choice between Ping iSi irons or modern irons ultimately depends on your individual golfing style and preferences. The Ping iSi irons may be better for you if you prefer a classic and simple design. 

Modern irons may be the way to go if you prefer advanced technology and materials that offer more forgiveness, control, and distance. 

When making your decision, it is important to consider factors such as the feel, launch conditions, forgiveness, versatility, and cost. 

It may also be helpful to test both options on the course and see which one performs better for you. Ultimately, the best iron for you is the one that allows you to perform at your best on the course.


Here are some related queries that golfers often seek answers to in different forums and groups. You may have a quick look to understand more about ping isi vs modern irons-

Which type of iron is best for a beginner golfer?

For beginner golfers, it is recommended to use modern cavity-back or game-improvement irons as they have a larger sweet spot and provide more forgiveness on off-center hits.

Which type of iron is best for a low-handicap golfer?

Low handicap golfers usually prefer blade-style or player’s cavity irons for their precision and control.

Do modern irons have better technology than Ping iSi irons?

Yes, modern irons generally have advanced technologies such as multi-material construction, perimeter weighting, and sole advanced designs, which offer improved performance compared to classic blade-style irons like the Ping iSi.

Can Ping iSi irons still be used in competitive play?

Yes, blade-style irons like the Ping iSi can still be used in competitive play, but they are less commonly seen on the course as many golfers prefer the added performance benefits of modern irons.

Blade-style irons like the Ping iSi tend to have a softer, more traditional feel at impact than modern cavity-back irons’ firmer feel.

Can Ping iSi irons be customized for individual swing characteristics?

Yes, Ping iSi irons can be customized for individual swing characteristics through the use of custom shafts and clubhead weights.

Are modern irons more forgiving than Ping ISI irons?

Yes, modern irons are generally more forgiving than blade-style irons like the Ping iSi, as they have a larger sweet spot and improved sole designs to reduce the effects of off-center hits.

Can Ping iSi irons provide more preciSion than modern irons?

Blade-style irons like the Ping iSi tend to provide more precision and control compared to modern cavity-back or game-improvement irons, which prioritize forgiveness and distance.

What is the recommended shaft type for Ping ISI irons?

Ping iSi irons are commonly fitted with steel shafts but can also be fitted with graphite shafts for added weight savings. The recommended shaft will depend on individual swing characteristics and preferences.